NOTE TO READERS: This article is a living, evolving resource connected to my Social Media Gainsayers video series. New sections, updates, and embedded episodes will be added as each video is released. If you’re following along on YouTube, this post serves as the full written curriculum, expanded commentary, and central hub for the entire series. Last Updated: July 21, 2026

How First-Century Religious Polemics Reappear in the Digital Age

Did you know that long before YouTube exposés, TikTok reaction videos, livestream debates, and thumbnails announcing that someone’s faith tradition had been “destroyed” or they “got cooked,” religious opponents were already employing a variety of tactics? These tactics included not only labels and ridicule but also the strategic use of selective evidence, harsh accusations of deception, and appeals to the prevailing orthodoxy of the time.

Throughout history, individuals and groups have engaged in polemical discourse, employing familiar patterns that transcend modern technology and social media platforms. While social media may amplify these exchanges and offer new avenues for expression, the fundamental dynamics of polemics—debate and dispute—are anything but new. They are deeply rooted in the fabric of human communication and interaction.

Understanding these historical parallels can offer valuable insights. However, it is crucial to recognize that for Latter-day Saints, acknowledging these patterns should not devolve into a license to demonize every critic. Instead, it calls upon us to foster a more nuanced approach to dialogue and engagement. This means we must strive for discernment without slipping into paranoia. We can hold firm convictions without succumbing to contempt for others.

In our conversations and debates, we want to aim to express truth in a manner that reflects the charity of Jesus Christ. This challenges us to engage thoughtfully and respectfully, even when faced with opposition. We are invited to navigate the complexities of faith, belief, and skepticism with a spirit of love and understanding, creating space for constructive dialogue rather than animosity. Ultimately, our response to criticism can be a powerful testament to the principles we uphold, embodying a spirit that upholds truth while also extending grace to those with whom we may disagree.

Read More »